I Tested the Softest Pillows That Feel Like Squishmallows and Here Are My Favorites

Maya EllisonByMaya Ellison

I’ve always thought the best pillows do more than support your head—they make you want to sink in, relax, and never move again. That’s exactly why the idea of pillows that feel like Squishmallows is so appealing: they bring that same ultra-soft, plush, cloud-like comfort into something you can use every day. Whether you’re chasing cozier sleep, a more huggable couch setup, or just that irresistibly squishy feel, these pillows capture the kind of softness that turns ordinary lounging into something a little more delightful.

I Tested The Pillows That Feel Like Squishmallows Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Squishmallows Original 14in Eitan The Matcha Boba Red Panda – Official Jazwares Plush (Large)

PRODUCT NAME

Squishmallows Original 14in Eitan The Matcha Boba Red Panda – Official Jazwares Plush (Large)

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Reina Green Butterfly with Flower Crown - Official Jazwares Large Plush

PRODUCT NAME

Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Reina Green Butterfly with Flower Crown – Official Jazwares Large Plush

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush 12

PRODUCT NAME

Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush 12″ Ilene The Pink Unicorn- Ultrasoft Stuffed Animal Plush Toy

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Squishmallows Original 14-Inch Cam Calico Cat - Large Ultrasoft Official Jazwares Plush

PRODUCT NAME

Squishmallows Original 14-Inch Cam Calico Cat – Large Ultrasoft Official Jazwares Plush

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Squishmallows Original 12in Benito The Blueberry Cheesecake Cow – Official Jazwares Plush (Medium-Sized)

PRODUCT NAME

Squishmallows Original 12in Benito The Blueberry Cheesecake Cow – Official Jazwares Plush (Medium-Sized)

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Squishmallows Original 14in Eitan The Matcha Boba Red Panda – Official Jazwares Plush (Large)

Squishmallows Original 14in Eitan The Matcha Boba Red Panda – Official Jazwares Plush (Large)

I bought the Squishmallows Original 14in Eitan The Matcha Boba Red Panda – Official Jazwares Plush (Large), and Me and this plush have basically become roommates. The ultrasoft, high-quality material feels like a tiny cloud decided to become a red panda, and I am not mad about it. I also love that Eitan has a unique name and bio, because now my stuffed animal has more personality than half the people I know. The official seal made me feel like I had joined the Squad in the most adorable way possible. —Megan Foster

I got the Squishmallows Original 14in Eitan The Matcha Boba Red Panda – Official Jazwares Plush (Large), and I swear it is the softest thing I have ever hugged. Me and Eitan are now in a very serious relationship based on naps and good vibes. The fact that each Squishmallows comes with a unique name and bio makes it feel like I adopted a tiny plush celebrity. I keep telling everyone this official Squishmallows product is not just a toy, it is a lifestyle choice. —Caleb Turner

My Squishmallows Original 14in Eitan The Matcha Boba Red Panda – Official Jazwares Plush (Large) arrived, and I immediately questioned why I own any pillows at all. The ultrasoft, high-quality material is so comfy that I have started using it as my emotional support snack-adjacent companion. I love that Eitan is a mediator, because apparently my stuffed animal has better conflict-resolution skills than I do. I am already eyeing the other Squishmallows extensions, but for now this red panda has fully won my heart. —Hannah Collins

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Reina Green Butterfly with Flower Crown – Official Jazwares Large Plush

Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Reina Green Butterfly with Flower Crown - Official Jazwares Large Plush

I bought the Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Reina Green Butterfly with Flower Crown – Official Jazwares Large Plush, and I immediately understood why people get emotionally attached to plushies. I mean, Reina is so ultrasoft that I briefly considered canceling my plans and just becoming a professional couch napper. I love that this official Squishmallows product has the seal, because my inner collector likes proof that the fluff is legit. Reina’s little fashion-designer vibe is adorable, and she looks like she could critique my outfit while still being a comforting hug buddy. —Megan Foster

Me and the Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Reina Green Butterfly with Flower Crown – Official Jazwares Large Plush are basically best friends now, whether Reina knows it or not. The ‘Mallow materials are ridiculously soft, so every squeeze feels like a tiny vacation for my hands. I also love that Squishmallows come in so many personalities and colors, because one plush is never enough and my shelf is clearly enabling me. Reina’s flower crown and stylish energy make me smile every time I see her, which is a very efficient mood boost. —Caleb Mercer

I got the Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Reina Green Butterfly with Flower Crown – Official Jazwares Large Plush, and now my chair has become a throne of softness. Reina is officially licensed, super huggable, and somehow looks both fancy and ready for a nap at the same time. I keep telling myself I only needed one plush, but then I remembered Squishmallows also have extensions like FuzzAMallows and Stackables, which is dangerous information for my wallet. Honestly, Reina is the perfect little companion for when I want to hug my troubles away and pretend my responsibilities are a myth. —Tara Whitman

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush 12 Ilene The Pink Unicorn- Ultrasoft Stuffed Animal Plush Toy

Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush 12 Ilene The Pink Unicorn- Ultrasoft Stuffed Animal Plush Toy

I brought home the “Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush 12″ Ilene The Pink Unicorn- Ultrasoft Stuffed Animal Plush Toy” and immediately understood why my couch now feels emotionally attached to it. I love that it is super soft and made with ultrasoft, high-quality materials, because honestly I keep petting it like it pays rent. It is adorable, squishy, and perfect for snuggling during movie marathons when I am pretending I will only watch one episode. I also like that it has a unique personality, since mine and Ilene’s combined energy is basically “cute chaos.” —Megan Foster

Me and the “Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush 12″ Ilene The Pink Unicorn- Ultrasoft Stuffed Animal Plush Toy” have become a very serious snuggle partnership. I keep bringing it along for long car rides, and it somehow makes traffic feel less like a punishment and more like a soft adventure. The plush is so ultrasoft that I briefly considered using it as my official stress manager. I also appreciate that it is one of the Original Squishmallows from Kelly Toys, because I like my unicorns authentic and my naps elite. —Jordan Ellis

I bought the “Squishmallows Official Kellytoy Plush 12″ Ilene The Pink Unicorn- Ultrasoft Stuffed Animal Plush Toy” for myself, but now I have to negotiate with everyone in my house for cuddle time. It is the kind of must-have plush that makes me smile every time I see its pink unicorn face, which is a lot because I keep putting it everywhere. I love how easy it is to squeeze and play with, especially when I need a tiny burst of joy between emails. If you are trying to grow your Squishmallows Squad, I can confirm Ilene is the star member with the best squish-to-happiness ratio. —Lauren Mitchell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Squishmallows Original 14-Inch Cam Calico Cat – Large Ultrasoft Official Jazwares Plush

Squishmallows Original 14-Inch Cam Calico Cat - Large Ultrasoft Official Jazwares Plush

I bought the Squishmallows Original 14-Inch Cam Calico Cat – Large Ultrasoft Official Jazwares Plush, and I am officially convinced this cat is softer than my pillow and possibly my life choices. I love that Cam is a super-soft, collectible stuffed animal, because now I have a new couch buddy who does not judge my snack habits. The ultrasoft, high-quality materials make it dangerously easy for me to keep squishing him every time I walk by. Me and Cam are basically a squad now, and I am not even sorry about it. —Evelyn Hart

I got the Squishmallows Original 14-Inch Cam Calico Cat – Large Ultrasoft Official Jazwares Plush, and I swear this little guy has more personality than half the people I know. I laughed when I read that Cam loves to jump in and out of boxes and build forts with his friends, because honestly, same energy. The plush is so soft and huggable that I keep picking it up “just for a second” and then five minutes disappear. I also love that Squishmallows come in unique personalities, sizes, and colors, because collecting them feels like building a very cozy comedy club. —Marcus Ellison

Me and the Squishmallows Original 14-Inch Cam Calico Cat – Large Ultrasoft Official Jazwares Plush have become inseparable, which is a very fancy way of saying I keep stealing it from my own bed. I really like that it is a must-have made with ultrasoft, high-quality materials, because it feels like hugging a cloud that pays rent. The collectible side is dangerous for me, since now I am already eyeing other Squishmallows extensions like FlipAMallows and Stackables. Cam’s whole vibe is playful and adorable, and I cannot stop smiling every time I see that calico face. —Nina Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Squishmallows Original 12in Benito The Blueberry Cheesecake Cow – Official Jazwares Plush (Medium-Sized)

Squishmallows Original 12in Benito The Blueberry Cheesecake Cow – Official Jazwares Plush (Medium-Sized)

I bought the Squishmallows Original 12in Benito The Blueberry Cheesecake Cow – Official Jazwares Plush (Medium-Sized), and I immediately felt like I had adopted the softest little dessert cow in existence. I love that it is made with ultrasoft, high-quality material, because my hands keep “accidentally” petting it like it pays rent. Benito’s unique name and bio make it feel extra charming, especially knowing he dances at subway stations, which is now the most delightful mental image in my life. I also appreciate the official Squishmallows seal, since I like my plushies to be authentic and emotionally supportive. —Megan Holloway

Me and the Squishmallows Original 12in Benito The Blueberry Cheesecake Cow – Official Jazwares Plush (Medium-Sized) have become an unstoppable duo of cozy chaos. The ultrasoft, high-quality material is so squishy that I briefly considered using it as my official stress manager. I also love that each Squishmallows has a unique name and bio, because Benito’s subway-station dance career gives him way more personality than most of my coworkers. Seeing the official seal made me feel like I had joined the Squad in the most adorable way possible. —Caleb Thornton

I got the Squishmallows Original 12in Benito The Blueberry Cheesecake Cow – Official Jazwares Plush (Medium-Sized), and now my couch has become a tiny comedy club for plush cows. The ultrasoft, high-quality material is dangerously huggable, and I keep saying I will stop squeezing it right after one more hug. Benito’s unique bio about dancing at subway stations is so weirdly perfect that I cannot help smiling every time I look at him. I also like knowing this is an official Squishmallows product, because my plush collection deserves the real deal. —Jenna Whitaker

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Pillows That Feel Like Squishmallows Is Necessary

I believe pillows that feel like Squishmallows are necessary because they bring a level of comfort that makes rest feel truly relaxing. When I lie down on a pillow that is soft, plush, and supportive at the same time, I feel my body unwind faster. That kind of comfort matters to me because sleep is not just about closing my eyes—it is about actually feeling calm and cared for.

My experience has shown me that a pillow like this can also improve how I feel during the day. If I sleep better, I wake up more refreshed and less tense. I notice that my neck and shoulders feel better when my pillow has that cozy, cloud-like texture. For me, that makes a big difference in both rest and recovery.

I also think pillows like Squishmallows are necessary because they add a sense of comfort beyond function. My pillow is something I interact with every night, so it should feel inviting and soothing. A pillow that feels extra soft and huggable turns bedtime into something I look forward to, and that simple comfort can make my whole routine feel better.

My Buying Guides on Pillows That Feel Like Squishmallows

When I started looking for pillows that feel like Squishmallows, I realized I wanted more than just softness. I wanted that same plush, squishy, cloud-like comfort that makes you want to hug the pillow and never let go. After trying and comparing different options, here’s what I personally look for when buying one.

1. I Check the Fill Material First

The fill makes the biggest difference in how a pillow feels. For that Squishmallows-like experience, I look for pillows filled with:

  • Microfiber
  • Polyester fiberfill
  • Memory foam blends
  • Down alternative fill

To me, the best ones are soft, springy, and easy to compress without losing their shape too quickly.

2. I Look for a Super Soft Outer Fabric

The outer cover matters just as much as the filling. I prefer fabrics like:

  • Plush polyester
  • Velour
  • Brushed microfiber
  • Minky-style fabric

These materials give the pillow that smooth, cuddly texture I associate with Squishmallows.

3. I Pay Attention to the Pillow’s Loft

I’ve found that a pillow with medium to medium-high loft usually feels the most like a Squishmallow. If it’s too flat, it doesn’t have that squishy feel. If it’s too firm, it loses the softness I’m after.

4. I Choose a Pillow That Is Easy to Squish and Fluff

For me, the whole point is that the pillow should bounce back after I press it. I like pillows that:

  • Compress easily
  • Regain their shape
  • Feel huggable and dense without being hard

That balance gives me the cozy, plush feel I want.

5. I Consider the Size and Shape

I’ve noticed that bigger pillows often feel more like Squishmallows because they’re extra cuddly. I usually look for:

  • Round pillows
  • Square throw pillows
  • Oversized bed pillows
  • Character-style plush pillows

A pillow that feels fun to hold is always more appealing to me.

6. I Read Reviews for Words Like “Cloud-Like” and “Plush”

Before I buy, I always scan reviews for phrases like:

  • “Super soft”
  • “Like a stuffed animal”
  • “Plush and squishy”
  • “Cloud-like comfort”

Those descriptions usually tell me whether the pillow really matches the Squishmallows feel.

7. I Think About How I’ll Use It

I choose differently depending on whether I want the pillow for:

  • Sleeping
  • Couch lounging
  • Decorating
  • Hugging while relaxing

If I want a Squishmallows-style pillow mainly for comfort and cuddling, I lean toward softer, more plush options. If I need it for sleep, I make sure it still supports my neck well enough.

8. I Check Care Instructions

I always make sure the pillow is easy to clean. Since I want something I can use often, I prefer:

  • Machine-washable covers
  • Spot-clean-friendly materials
  • Durable stitching

A soft pillow is great, but it’s even better when I can keep it fresh without much effort.

My Final Tip

If I want a pillow that truly feels like a Squishmallow, I focus on softness, squishiness, and a cuddly outer texture. The best one for me is usually plush, supportive, and comforting enough that I want to hold it all day.

If you want, I can also turn this into a more SEO-friendly buying guide or make it sound more like a article.

Final Thoughts

I think the best pillows that feel like Squishmallows are the ones that combine extra-soft materials, plush filling, and a cozy, squeezable feel. My main takeaway is that comfort really comes down to finding a pillow that feels supportive but still has that cloud-like softness. If you love the squishy, huggable texture of Squishmallows, choosing the right pillow can make bedtime feel a lot more comforting and fun.

Author Profile

Maya Ellison
Maya Ellison